Penguin Power Page
'Penguin Power' Propels the Navy
Business Week 12 May 1997 Page 107 "Developments to Watch" section
by Paul C. Judge
Engineers have tried for more than a century to improve on the simple but inefficient ship's propeller. The latest effort is based on penguin flippers. Massachusetts Institute of Technology researchers have built a propulsion system that utilized two oscillating blades that produce thrust by sweeping back and forth in opposite directions.
A 12-foot scale model of the "penguin boat" has shown promise in early lab trials. The blades achieved about 87% efficiency, compared with 70% in conventional ships - which translates into lower fuel consumption. MIT researchers calculate that converting only 3% of the U.S. shipping fleet to a propulsion system that increases efficiency by just 10% would save some $15 million per year.
Based on laboratory results, MIT's penguin boat is capable of moving as fast as conventional propeller driven craft - and it may be easier to maneuver. All this information interests the U.S. Navy, which supports the project through the Office of Naval Research.
PROTEUS THE PENGUIN BOAT
Source: MIT web site
The Proteus project is the challenge of pragmatically applying highly efficient natural fish propulsion technologies to conventional vessels.
One hundred and fifty million years of evolution has enabled fish to develop extremely efficient technologies for aquatic propulsion and maneuvering. Recent experimental, MIT Robo-tuna, and computational studies confirmed this. However, because these studies were based on models with undulating bodies, direct application to ships and submarines is not possible. Our goal was to apply the promising "fish" technologies to conventional marine vessels pragmatically.
Success could mean the savings of millions of marine transport dollars and subsequent environmental damage, autonomous ocean research vessels covering more territory, and military submarines evading their foe because their "fish wake" is difficult to detect. An extensive literature review and discussions with marine hydrodynamics experts showed that efficient propulsion may be obtained by the oscillation of a foil without an undulating body. For example, large whales and other oscillating foil propelled animals requiring high efficiency employ the thunniform mode of swimming, which consists primarily of tail oscillation. Other animals, such as marine turtles or penguins, obtain efficient propulsion by pectoral flipper oscillation alone.
In this spirit, a boat foil propulsion design was developed with two foils moving out of phase so that thrust would be the only net force and vertical foil orientation allowing for the possibility of thrust maneuvering with thrust vectoring. The challenge of actuating the foils with the appropriate "fish" motion was first met with a prototype mechanical device capable of oscillating two foils with limited independent adjustment of the foil's heave, pitch, frequency and phase between the motions. First-ever autonomous operation and wake visualization experiments were conducted and yielded useful results. The shortcomings of the first mechanism where met with a remote controlled four-degree of freedom robotic mechanism. Advanced mechanical design and state of the art electronics allow this 3.4 meter long oscillating foil propelled boat to produce accurate efficiency measurements over a wide range of operating parameters. Results from preliminary experiments are very encouraging.
Proteus the Penguin Boat in the News
Source: MIT web site
MIT 'Penguin Boat' Takes Maiden Voyage Down Charles River
Source: MIT web site
Proteus, a "penguin boat" developed by graduate student James Czarnowski and inspired by "Robotuna," is propelled by two flipper-like oscillating foils (at right). Photo by Donna Coveney, MIT News Office.
Proteus, an experimental 'penguin boat' propelled by oscillating foils, moves down the Charles River in front of the Boston skyline during an early-morning test run. Photo by Donna Coveney, MIT News Office.
04/03/97 MIT 'Penguin Boat' Takes Maiden Voyage Down Charles River
MIT News Office Massachusetts Institute of Technology Room 5-111 77 Massachusetts Avenue Cambridge, MA 02139-4307 Phone: 617-253-2700 NOTE: PHOTOS AVAILABLE. ================================ MIT's `penguin boat' takes maiden voyage down Charles River ================================ New propulsion system could lead to more efficient ships For Immediate Release, April 3, 1997 Contact: Elizabeth A. Thomson Phone: (617) 258-5402 Fax: (617) 258-8762 E-mail: <firstname.lastname@example.org> CAMBRIDGE, Mass--Zipping along through the water, the penguin uses two flippers to propel its rigid body quickly and efficiently. Now MIT engineers have applied that "technology" to a man-made vehicle that recently took its maiden voyage down a short stretch of the Charles River. Introducing Proteus the Penguin Boat, a 12-foot craft with two "oscillating foils," or flippers, attached to its stern. Named after the son of the sea god Poseidon, Proteus could lead to full-scale ships that move more efficiently--and consume less fuel--than those using traditional propellers. (An experimental model, Proteus is too narrow to fit even a single passenger.) The boat is the first of its kind. In the past researchers have performed theoretical computations for propelling a boat with flippers, but until now no-one had built one. Preliminary tests are promising. The new propulsion system when tested in the laboratory reached up to 87 percent efficiency. The system as implemented on the boat "is still being evaluated since many of the components are novel and require further development," said Michael S. Triantafyllou, a professor in the Department of Ocean Engineering who leads the research team. Professor Triantafyllou noted that the average efficiency of existing ships is at or below about 70 percent. According to 1992 US Fuel and Shipping Statistics, "converting only three percent of the United States shipping fleet to a propulsor with 10 percent higher efficiency would mean an [annual] monetary savings of $15 million and 120 million fewer liters of petroleum fuel being burned," wrote James T. Czarnowski, a graduate student in the Departments of Ocean Engineering and Mechanical Engineering, in a paper he and two MIT undergraduates will be presenting on the work at the May 1997 International Society of Offshore and Polar Engineers (ISOPE) conference. FISH-LIKE PREDECESSOR Proteus is a direct descendant of robotuna, another biologically inspired MIT creation. This four-foot-long robotic fish, patterned after a bluefin tuna, was designed to test the efficiency of a single oscillating foil--a fish's tail. That efficiency proved to be about 85 percent, under conditions of developing the amount of force required normally by marine vehicles, and in 1995 MIT was awarded a patent on the propulsion mechanism. "The experimental work on the robotuna foil showed high efficiency and high promise. So the next focus was to give it a real-life application," said Professor Triantafyllou. But ships patterned after the robotuna itself, whose entire body swishes back and forth as it moves through the water, aren't practical. "We thought that if we could remove the body and just keep the tail, we could take a lot of the good from the tuna without the need to have the undulating body," Mr. Czarnowski said. conducting a feasibility study, Mr. Czarnowski spent six months building a six-foot prototype. The device showed enough promise that Professor Triantafyllou gave the go-ahead to develop a more advanced version. Among other things, when the engineers studied the wake of the prototype they found that it closely resembled the wakes of the robotuna and of living tropical fish (Danios). "That was important because it showed us that with two flippers we were producing the same hydrodynamics that a fish tail produces and therefore we should see As with the robotuna, Nature also helped the engineers with the new design. "Penguins and sea turtles are the biological analogies to what we were looking for," Mr. Czarnowski explained. "Both have rigid bodies like a boat, and propulsion is achieved through oscillation of pectoral flippers." After videotaping penguins at the New England Aquarium and similar efficiencies," Mr. Czarnowski said. So a little over a year later, Mr. Czarnowski, Professor Triantafyllou, and colleagues produced Proteus. The multidisciplinary team included three undergraduates: Timothy R. Cleary, a senior in the Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics; William R. Kreamer, a junior in the Department of Ocean Engineering, and Michael C. Murphy, a senior in the Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science. Czarnowski, Cleary, and Kreamer will be presenting the work at the ISOPE conference. Proteus allows the researchers to study a wider range of flipper motions than the prototype was capable of, and also allows them to more accurately measure the propulsion mechanism's efficiency. "The prototype was entirely mechanical and was built using 19th-century technology," Mr. Czarnowski explained, "whereas Proteus uses state-of-the-art robotics. It's also twice as big, so we can measure larger forces and have a wake that's easier to visualize." The boat, which is about 1 1/2 feet wide by 12 feet long, is a scale model of a fast ship. Packed inside are two car batteries, a 486 desktop computer, a power-sensing circuit, and a voltage converter that changes the battery power into the power used by the computer and by the four motors that control the motion of the flippers. Two large motors allow the flippers to move toward and away from each other; two smaller motors allow them to twist slightly as they do so. Before the researchers send the boat for a run down the Charles River, they program it for a specific "flapping motion" of the flippers. These commands are relayed to the onboard computer via a monitor and keyboard that are then disconnected from the computer and remain on the shore. Once Proteus begins moving through the water it is controlled by a remote control. The same remote control also allows the researchers to start recording (via the onboard computer) how much power the motors are using. That data, in turn, allows them to calculate the efficiency of each run. "Once we determine the most efficient flapping motion on the Charles," said Mr. Czarnowski, "we want to bring the boat back to the MIT Testing Tank to study the wake so we know what an efficient wake looks like." Future work includes designing a flipper system that allows for maneuvering as well as propulsion. Currently Proteus can only move in a straight line. As a result, for tests on the Charles the boat is attached via two guides on its left to a long string of fishing line that in turn is strung between two piers. Once it has completed a run from one pier to the other, one of the researchers hauls it back to the "start" with a fishing pole. A LOVE FOR BOATS Jim Czarnowski has always loved boats. "I've been building strange little boats like this since I was eight years old," he said. "My first one was a papier-mache paddle-wheel boat with a small electric motor that powered a popsicle-stick paddle wheel. Now that I'm at MIT I can build more advanced models." What's been the best part of the Proteus project? "Finally seeing it work, and having everyone who's worked so hard on it enjoying that success as well," Mr. Czarnowski said. He also likes sharing the excitement with others. Every test on the Charles has drawn an audience, even though those tests at the MIT Sailing Pavilion begin at about 5:30 in the morning to take advantage of the calm conditions on the river. "Seeing their curiosity and explaining to them what we are doing is very rewarding," he said. The work is supported by the Office of Naval Research and the MIT Sea Grant College Program.